In Making Democracy Count: How Mathematics Improves Voting, Electoral Maps, and Representation, Ismar Volić undertakes a compelling examination of the intersection between mathematics and democracy. As the United States grapples with persistent challenges in its electoral system, Volić’s work is a timely contribution, offering a rigorous analysis of how mathematical principles can enhance the fairness and integrity of democratic processes.
A Rigorous Exploration of Democracy Through Mathematics
Volić’s thesis is clear: the functioning of democracy, particularly in the realm of voting and representation, can be significantly improved through the application of mathematical concepts. This is not a superficial argument; Volić delves deep into the mathematical underpinnings of voting systems and electoral mapping, providing a robust framework for understanding how these abstract principles have concrete implications for governance.
The book is structured into three distinct sections—Voting, Representation, and Civic Infrastructure—each of which meticulously breaks down the relevant mathematical theories and their practical applications. Volić’s approach is both methodical and accessible, ensuring that readers, regardless of their background in mathematics, can grasp the critical ideas. However, this accessibility does not come at the expense of depth; the author engages with complex mathematical concepts, presenting them in a manner that is both thorough and intellectually stimulating.
Critical Assessment of Volić’s Argumentation
One of the standout features of Volić’s work is his ability to translate complex mathematical ideas into actionable insights for democratic reform. For example, his critique of the plurality voting system—a method that has long been criticized for its inability to reflect the true preferences of the electorate—is particularly incisive. Volić doesn’t merely point out the flaws; he offers alternative voting systems, such as ranked-choice voting, that could lead to more representative outcomes. His mathematical analysis of these systems is both rigorous and persuasive, making a strong case for their adoption.
However, while Volić’s arguments are mathematically sound, there is a tendency to overlook the broader socio-political context in which these reforms would be implemented. Democracy, as Volić acknowledges, is not just about numbers; it is also about power, politics, and human behavior. The mathematical solutions he proposes, while theoretically robust, may face significant obstacles in practical implementation. This is a point that could have been explored in greater depth, particularly given the current political climate in the United States.
Volić’s discussion of gerrymandering is another highlight of the book. He effectively demonstrates how mathematical tools can be used to detect and prevent this form of electoral manipulation. The use of symmetry and bias metrics to assess the fairness of electoral maps is a particularly innovative approach, and Volić provides compelling evidence that these methods could lead to more equitable representation. Yet, as with his proposals on voting reform, the challenge lies in the political feasibility of these mathematical solutions. Gerrymandering is a deeply entrenched practice, and the mathematical fairness Volić advocates for may be difficult to achieve in practice without significant political will.
Contextualizing Volić’s Work in Contemporary Discourse
Volić’s arguments are situated within the broader context of American political discourse, making the book highly relevant to contemporary debates on democracy. He does not shy away from addressing the shortcomings of the U.S. Electoral College, the manipulation of voting districts, and the challenges of enacting reform in a polarized political environment. By embedding his mathematical proposals within these real-world challenges, Volić enhances the practical relevance of his work.
Nevertheless, the book could benefit from a more nuanced discussion of the political obstacles to implementing these mathematical reforms. While Volić is clear about the mathematical advantages of his proposals, he does not fully engage with the political realities that might hinder their adoption. For instance, while ranked-choice voting and fair districting are mathematically superior, they face significant resistance from established political interests. A deeper exploration of these political barriers would have added a valuable dimension to the book.
A Narrative Style That Engages and Informs
Volić’s writing is characterized by a clear, narrative style that blends academic rigor with engaging storytelling. He uses anecdotes effectively to illustrate how mathematical principles apply to real-world democratic processes. The opening chapter, which recounts a fourth-grade classroom voting on a movie, is a particularly effective example. This simple scenario vividly illustrates the limitations of the plurality voting system and sets the stage for the more complex discussions that follow.
However, while Volić’s narrative is engaging, there are moments where the mathematical details may overwhelm readers who are less mathematically inclined. Despite his best efforts to simplify these concepts, the inherent complexity of the subject matter may still pose a challenge for some readers. Nonetheless, Volić succeeds in making a strong case for why everyone—not just mathematicians—should care about the mathematics that underpins democracy.
Conclusion: A Thoughtful and Timely Contribution
Making Democracy Count is a significant contribution to the ongoing conversation about the future of democracy in the United States. Volić offers a compelling argument for the importance of mathematical literacy in safeguarding democratic institutions. His proposals are innovative and backed by rigorous analysis, making this book essential reading for anyone interested in the intersection of mathematics and politics.
While the book’s ambitious scope may lead to some areas being less fully explored, it remains a powerful call to action. Volić challenges readers to rethink their assumptions about democracy and consider how mathematical tools can help create a more just and representative political system. In an era where democracy is increasingly under threat, Making Democracy Count offers both a diagnosis and a potential solution, grounded in the precision and objectivity of mathematics.
About Author
